I love Christians. Really. Catholics are especially hot, and I’ve even dated a Mormon or two.
I grew up in the bible-belt of south-east Idaho, just three hours away from Salt Lake City, Utah. Where we lived you were some form of Christianity (including a heavy Catholic population comprised of immigrant workers), Mormon, or non-denominational. If you happened to be atheist or agnostic you were either quiet about it or an angry high school kid like I was. In my tiny school full of cowboys, jocks, and preps it was unheard of to be non-religious which made the last couple years of high school very interesting at times. This article aside, my days of arguing religion are long over. I learned after a few years of beating my head against a brick wall that nobody wins religious debates. I tried hard though, often.
It wasn’t always so. While my family has always been spiritual, both parents had a distaste for organized religion. That, and my dad worked 24/7 and my mom hated getting up early. And being judged. Still, I got together with the devout family a mile down the road and for a time during my childhood I got dressed up and piled into their van to sing “Jesus Loves Me” in English and Spanish. I can’t remember how my church going days came to an end, but then came church camp. Insert heavenly choir here. Church camp was amazing: Camping, s’mores, ping pong, hikes in the mountains, and the cutest non-local girls a kid from a town of a thousand could hope for. Some of my most romantic and exciting virginal action happened at church camp. Even when moving from curious, to agnostic, to atheist I still looked forward to camp every summer. And not just for the girls. Christians can be some of the coolest, nicest, most caring people in the world. Especially at a time and place that has a high concentration of piety.
So when I received interview advice suggesting I let people know right off the bat that I was an atheist there was only a small amount of worry. At worst I figured I get prayed at really hard. Deflecting jokes about being stabbed by angry followers I’d reply, “Hey, that would make a great story too!” Sadly traffic and the format of the event (I didn’t expect the entire thing to be assigned seating for some reason) prevented me from interviewing anyone besides a security guard so there were no prayer-stares or knife fights.
We show up at the Norfolk Scope Arena about fifteen minutes before the event is set to begin. Hanging out by the literally blue-watered fountain while my photographer (read: girlfriend) snaps some pictures I begin to take in the crowd. Everyone is dressed in nice clothes, whether it’s shorts and flip-flops or the more popular jeans and a golf shirt. A few men are wearing suits and look like ministers themselves. A large woman in a grey jogging outfit with pink stripes walks by hefting a well-worn bible and I notice about one in every five people are as well. Everyone seems financially comfortable to well-off and I’m seeing a lot of big housewife asses. At 7:30 the line on our side of the Scope is wrapped around the squat rectangular fountain and car traffic is still backed up on the surrounding streets. I hear a few mellow complaints but the line is moving quickly and people are smiling in high spirits. You can tell everyone is expecting a good old fashioned time, like this is a Neil Diamond concert or something.
Entering the building I wonder not for the first time if there will be popcorn. The concession stands are up and running, selling $4 waters and $6 hot dogs. And event staffer helps us find our sections and by providence we’re on the isle. As my photographer snaps away and I start up my voice recorder and take notes I experience a feeling of paranoia, like everyone can tell we’re non-believers, like they can smell it on us. When the announcer asks everyone to stand I feel a palpable wave of peer pressure for just a moment but stay seated. Luckily the lady next to me stays in her seat as well so our infiltration feels less obvious. The seats around us are already filled and most of the Scope seems that way, too. Later a security guard tells us that the event sold out so they added more seats, only to have those sell out as well. A sort of opening act is underway and the man mentions the t-shirts, books, and CDs that are available for purchase. A pair of women behind us comment, not without bitterness, that the shirts are $25 a pop. We see the t-shirts as we walk around during one of the blaring musical numbers. They have slogans like, “Hope Is Alive”, “I Can Do All Things!”, and “More Than A Conqueror”. The one shirt I do see with obvious religious text simply has the bible citation in tiny letters below the huge text. The shirts are inspirational but not blatantly Christian.
Which is much like the Joel Osteen Ministry itself. His Lakewood Church is non-denominational and based out of Texas, which happens to boast the largest congregation in America. It used to be a sports arena and, just like the t-shirts, is absent of religious symbols like alters or even a cross. During the multiple sermons punctuated by energetic musical performances I keep a tally of how often he mentions sin and quotes from the bible. Critics of Joel Osteen say that both are lacking from his sermons and from the videos available on JoelOsteen.com I can see what they mean. Tonight I count about fifteen scripture references but only two mentions of sin. And both were in a positive manner as in, “...by standing up tonight all your sins have been forgiven...” and, “God isn’t mad at you, he’s already forgiven your sins...” Now, I haven’t been to church in some years but apparently fifteen bible verses isn’t enough. To his critics it seems like Joel Osteen’s cardinal sin is being too positive. Well that and spreading “prosperity gospel”, which teaches that God rewards the pious with health, wealth, and happiness.
Which may very well account for his immense popularity. His physical church in Houston averages 43,500 attendees per week and his media broadcasts reach over seven million viewers weekly in more than one hundred countries. It’s reported that Joel Osteen is personally worth $40 million. One of the questions I had for my possible interviewees was, “Why Joel Osteen?” During my research and after the night’s event the question seemed unnecessary; even this heathen can understand his allure: He has a plan for happiness and success (a plan that is apparently working out very well for him) as well as for getting into heaven. Not only will God take care of you in this life, this relationship, this economy, but once your time here is done you’ll be taken care of in Heaven forever and ever amen. You’re set in both realms, the earthly and the spiritual. I don't know about you, but I find that a much more attractive offer than wanting in this (very real) life to possibly secure happiness in another existence that no living person has ever seen. Even for the faithful that must be a hard wafer to swallow at times.
The religious and secular friends I spoke with all see Joel Osteen as a swindler, only after people’s money by baiting them with empty promises of wealth and success, and that prosperity gospel in general is wrong. I disagree, at least on the latter point. In the old days success and wealth meant good crops, a plentiful catch, or however people fed themselves and had goods to trade. “Give us today our daily bread”, as the Lord’s Prayer goes. Nowadays though everything is done with money. No one raises their own food or uses the barter system to take care of their earthly needs. So if God is going to make sure His people are secure and have their daily bread that necessitates money to go and buy some. Praying for financial success is the new praying for bountiful harvests. I may be playing devil’s advocate here, but I have no problem with prosperity gospel. It seems no different to me than the host of other claims religious people make on a daily basis, regardless of their gospel.
However I can see how it would be a very slippery and dangerous slope. Jesus taught to be generous and humble, which you could do with millions I suppose, but it’s difficult and rare. Remember the cup that Indiana Jones chooses in Last Crusade? It’s a plain wooden goblet (although the inside does appear to be lined with gold. Metaphor?) and it’s the first image I see any time I think about Jesus. I get the impression of a relaxed and groovy guy wandering about and helping people; and I think this image of a simple, thrifty Jesus is more in line with his teachings than some of what Joel Osteen is saying.
I could just be thinking of Matthew 19:24 though: “Again I tell you, it is easier for a camel to go through the eye of a needle than for a rich man to enter the kingdom of God.” (Thanks, Kids In The Hall) Now they aren’t coming right out and saying it, but aren’t they heavily implying that it’s impossible to go to heaven if you’re rich? This seems to be the main point of friction between “regular” and prosperity gospel. Of course even those that don’t subscribe to Joel Osteen’s particular brand of Christianity seem to ignore Matthew 19:24 and the other multiple places it appears in the bible. People may complain that Joel Osteen teaches God will give you health and wealth for being a good follower but lay and ordained Christians of every denomination pray for that raise, a good husband, a new car, to beat an illness, to get through the day. We’ve all tried to make a deal with the Almighty for something we really want. If God has control over every detail of our lives I’d definitely want Him to include my finances and health in His plan.
Joel Osteen himself comes across as funny and charismatic, often laughing at himself and always, always, always with a grin. The one time I saw anything but a smile on his face is when he briefly broke down crying on stage. My research had warned me about this and I saved a space to tally the amount of times he cried, but it only happened the one time. His huge, white grin makes his already small eyes look tiny and he has dark full hair that doesn’t seem to move. His wife and co-pastor Victoria has long blond hair, blue eyes, and looks like the poster woman for the perfect Texan wife. They stand together onstage, bathed in blue and white light from above, at the base of a huge onscreen cross towering above them. As I watch them on the distant stage or the gigantic media screens I can’t help but think of The Fellowship of the Sun, the fictional church bent on purging the world of vampires in the True Blood universe and how Joel and Victoria have to be the basis for the husband and wife characters that preside over it. They have Texan accents and chime in here and there on each other’s stories, and when Joel covers his face to cry she rubs his back. Each of them have books and CDs of their own for sale and Victoria does children’s literature. Early in the night Joel recounts the story of how they met and how glad he was when he found out she was already a good Christian girl. He jokes that it saved him the trouble of having to convert her and the whole place comes alive with laughter.
Joel’s mother makes an appearance to testify that God saved her life and gave her the strength to survive terminal liver cancer when doctors didn’t know what to do and gave up. Shortly after that a woman from the choir takes center stage and tells a similar story about a (implied non-Christian) doctor that refused to operate on her massive goiters when they didn’t know what was causing it. (I began to sense a pattern but luckily those were the only testimonies I saw that night.) Through her tears, the woman explained, she still felt that God had a plan for her, and she was able to find a calm, professional, Christian doctor on the Internet who’d done goiter operations in third-world countries and through God’s power she was healed. Not only that, but she didn’t even lose her singing range as the callous secular doctors had cautioned may happen. She exclaimed to applause, “With men it may be impossible, but with God all things are possible!”
I can’t help but recall a time when I provided tech support to a Christian architect that used painfully old and personalized drafting software. One day he had majorly screwed something up and unless I got it back to normal he was seriously fudged, to put it politely. After some tense trial and error (with him pacing behind me or watching over my shoulder) I fixed it and he clapped me on the back excitedly exclaiming, “Thank you Jesus!” I smiled ruefully and thought, “No, thank me!” Over the applause the woman continued, “God had pre-picked a surgeon for me!” Call me cynical but God also “pre-picked” the goiters and the resultant stress of losing what I assume to be her profession and her passion. Continuing my cynicism I have to point out that the Internet where she found the doctor, the science behind the medical training he received, the successful operation, etc: all made possible by man. Give unto Caesar that which is Caesar’s.
She segued seamlessly into a song and we used the opportunity to walk around a bit and look for potential interview subjects. Sadly the music was too loud to really talk to anyone hanging around outside. Walking the circumference of the Scope we noted that the t-shirt stands were shut down and the food vendors were following suit. The outdoor smoking area was only occupied by one or two people and a tall man wearing red, white, and blue carried a fussing baby around with a bemused look on his face. The security guard we talked to told us the concerts and even the hockey events they host are all calm, but in comparison this was dead. He’s quick to say he’s not bored though; the Scope is his home away from home, especially during hockey season. Curious, I ask him what events are the craziest and ironically he says The Jonas Brothers were the worst. He’s worked Warped Tours, Carnivals of Mayhem, etc, but nothing compares to the high-pitched squeal of teenage girls. He won’t be forgetting his ear plugs for the upcoming Justin Bieber concert.
We head back in through a different section to get a new vantage point and my photographer leaves me to boldly try to get closer to the stage. At one point Joel asks all the military people to stand up and I’m surprised at their low numbers. Even when he augments this with the families of those who proudly serve it’s still less than I’d expect. During the last sermon and blessing I notice that a lot of the event staff are standing in the back. I catch one woman falling asleep on her feet so I’m not sure if they’re present for inspiration or to get a jump on tear-down.
The final sermon is composed of blessings and advice from Joel, the first and most surprising of which is for everyone to find a local bible-based church to join, gushing that there are some great ones in the area. They’re glad if people like watching them on TV but to really develop a local church is needed, he explains. As he says this an abortive applause is heard and dies out in about three claps. He warns us about friends that will pull us away from the Lord, and if you love ‘em and don’t want to leave ‘em, “take ‘em to church!” He tells us all our sins are washed away, forget the past, and don’t let people throw your mistakes in your face and make you negative. His final word of advice is to talk to God everyday, like you’re talking to a good friend. Then he began to bless us. I can’t ever recall being blessed before so my ears perked up at this. “Everyone under the sound of [his] voice” became blessed with all manner of positive things: Creativity, good choices, courage, success, health, wealth, promotion, and long life. Joel broke all curses and negativity, personal and familial, and asked everyone that had been blessed to shout “Amen!” I was tempted, I really was.
---
The next morning I awoke in a good mood, with vague feelings of being able to start over. Start something over; I wasn’t sure what.
As I feed my son the first bottle of the day and inspect this curious positivity I’m in no fear of losing my atheistic integrity. If we had attended a nihilism rally instead I would have been affected by that the next day, too. I went in with an open mind and while my personal beliefs filtered out the theistic parts the upbeat and positive portions still got in. Joel Osteen really does have the perfect recipe to reach and inspire people: God will take care of your health, success, and finances in this life and lift you up to Heaven once it’s over; He is not mad at you and has already forgiven all your sins; the past doesn’t matter and don’t let anyone make you feel bad about it; the creator of the Universe will not let you fail. Add in heavy amounts of positivity and hope, sprinkle with self-empowerment, leave out the negative bits about sin and hell, and put it on TV. Bam! As another popular TV persona says. You’ve got yourself a great product.
I hadn’t been particularly inspired by the previous evening, though. If anything I felt underwhelmed. I suppose a part of me was expecting some over the top Christian antics like speaking in tongues (glossolalia is the scientific term) or frenzied dancing. I barely even saw people doing that creepy arms-raised-to-God thing they show on TV and I somehow missed the few crying people as they left the venue, although my photographer spotted them. But Joel Osteen Ministries is not one of those snake handling churches and the man himself gives the impression of being a normal, down to Earth kinda guy so it only makes sense that his followers would be regular Joes, too. No circus for the theologically challenged, just average folks looking to be inspired.
And really, if we remove the specifics from a lot of religious teachings they all come down to the same things: Life is tough, bad things happen, but you can do something about it. Don’t kill people or take their things; try to be nice; and the afterlife, this life, or both will be better. It’ll be okay. And that’s all anyone wants, to have someone who cares tell them everything is going to be alright.